The Chronicle editorial page  has some sense of humor! I’m sure they’ve taught that Ammiano a thing or two.

Herrera Concludes Supervisor Daly Domiciled
in District He Represents

San Francisco City Attorney Dennis Herrera.
Photo by Luke Thomas

From the Office of City Attorney Dennis Herrera

Editor’s Note: Supervisor Chris Daly’s reaction to Herrera’s conclusion: “Hats off to City Attorney Ethics Team Chief Jon Givner and Chief of Investigations Thomas Boyd for being so thorough in their investigation. I hope that the people who have writing spurious things about me, read this document.”

August 17, 2009

Analysis of Documents, Interviews Corroborate Supervisor’s Assertion That He Remains Legally Domiciled on Stevenson Street in San Francisco

City Attorney Dennis Herrera today published the conclusions of his office’s investigation and legal analysis into questions surrounding the legal domicile of District Six Supervisor Chris Daly, who along with his wife, Sarah Low Daly, recently purchased two houses in Fairfield, Calif. The City Attorney’s probe, which was initiated after Daly volunteered to be investigated late last month following his announcement of the purchases, concludes “that Supervisor Daly currently remains a resident of District Six, as required by the San Francisco Charter.”

Daly has maintained that he continues to reside at the couple’s condominium on Stevenson Street in San Francisco, where he has lived since Nov. 2001. His wife and two children recently relocated to Fairfield. The 15-page public memorandum jointly authored by City Attorney Ethics Team Chief Jon Givner and Chief of Investigations Thomas Boyd found the following:

“Supervisor Daly has consistently stated that he spends most of his time in San Francisco and that he intends to remain at the Stevenson Street residence. His actions — as evidenced by witness observations as well as public and private documents — corroborate that intent. We have reviewed a number of documents, including Department of Motor Vehicle registration records, voter registration records, tax returns, utility and related bills, homeowner’s exemption records, and other public documents, all of which are consistent with Supervisor Daly’s assertions and link him to the Stevenson Street residence. In contrast, we are aware of no documents that demonstrate Supervisor Daly has changed his domicile to Fairfield. Additionally, a number of witnesses, including Ms. Low Daly, Supervisor Daly’s Stevenson Street roommates and third party neighbors in San Francisco and in Fairfield, corroborate his statements. Based on our inspection of his bedroom and other rooms in the unit, it appears that Supervisor Daly resides at least part-time at Stevenson Street.

“Applying the established legal standard, we conclude that Supervisor Daly currently remains a resident of District Six. Under the Charter, he must remain a resident of that district and intend that it continue to be his fixed home for as long as he remains in office as the District Six Supervisor. We do not reach any conclusions here about whether Supervisor Daly’s domicile will change at any point in the future.”

The City Attorney’s memorandum additionally offers a comparative analysis of facts and applicable laws involving the office’s 2007 investigation into the residency of former Supervisor Ed Jew, whose failure to establish legal domicile in San Francisco’s District Four prior to seeking that office violated provisions of the City Charter and contributed, in part, to his decision to resign the office in January 2008. Daly’s disclosure last month of his family’s property purchases in Fairfield led several news organizations to draw parallels between the two district supervisors and the extent to which each met the residency requirements of state and local law.

A PDF copy of the complete City Attorney memorandum on Sup. Daly’s legal domicile is available online at the following URL:

http://www.sfcityattorney.org

Last year we elected a community organizer to the White House. But we need good community organizers at every level of our Party. That is why I have decided to run for Region 4 Director of the California Democratic Party, and that is why I am asking you for your support.

While I may be best known for getting things done in San Francisco’s rough and tumble political world, my roots are in community organizing. I moved to San Francisco as an organizer to work on issues of homelessness and poverty. Over the next 8 years I organized on San Francisco’s streets and in residential hotels –in working class, immigrant neighborhoods and communities of color– on issues of affordable housing, tenants rights, social services, immigrant rights and police accountability. Make no mistake about it, as tough as my current job is, it’s never matched the challenges I faced as an organizer on some of the toughest issues in communities forgotten by the powers that be, or even worse, communities under siege.

Years of community organizing didn’t just ground me in my political work, it led me to the Obama for America campaign. Two years ago I began to notice that some of the best young organizers in our City were leaving for other parts of the country to join the campaign. As a movement politician, I felt compelled to follow their lead. I realized that while Obama was an impressive candidate, the real beauty was in the Obama organization that laid the foundation for a widespread movement for change.

This movement, that we all became a part of at some point along the way, didn’t just deliver the Presidency to a progressive Democrat, it gave us an opportunity to continue the politics of hope and change. But like any movement built around a candidate, the challenge of keeping it going to affect lasting change over time is even greater than the challenge of winning an election. The architects of the Obama operation seem to understand this. They have launched Organizing for America through the Democratic National Committee to help implement an agenda of change in Washington.

While change has become a buzzword of nearly every Democrat, the commitment to enact that change is not as universal. Organizing is difficult work, and it’s true that we still need our policy wonks, fundraisers, and deal-makers. But in order to affect the change we need, we have to organize the structures to help facilitate that change. I believe that structure needs to be created in the California Democratic Party. Like Obama’s South Carolina operation, we here in Region 4 have the ability to organize the structures for change that can be replicated across the state of California.

The resources are most certainly here to do it – from progressive elected officials to the netroots, from organized labor to issue-based advocates, and from the youthful energy unleashed by the Obama campaign to those at the center of liberation struggles, most recently fighting against Prop 8. But in order to build a structure to facilitate lasting change, we will need a Regional Director with a vision, drive, and capability. As an active member of the San Francisco Democratic County Central Committee, a convener of the San Francisco Young Dems, the Democratic choice for District 6 Supervisor, and most importantly, as a community organizer, I am ready to take on this task. I believe that you are ready as well.

Join me in Sacramento on Saturday, April 25th, as we begin this task at the California Democratic Convention. And please feel free to email me here or call or text me on my cell phone with any questions, comments, or suggestions.

Together we can!

Chris Daly

“I’m asking people like you who fought for change in the campaign to continue fighting for change in your communities.” – Barack Obama

As Rick Warren prepares to deliver his invocation, it’s clear that the Obama Administration will have its disappointments. But I believe that the exact program of the Obama Administration is less important than what we do. Barack Obama seems to get this too.

Let’s take advantage of this opportunity and keep the organizing pressure on.

I called Ross Mirkarimi early this morning to get a clarification on this letter that appeared in today’s San Francisco Bay Guardian. I have not yet received a call back. With more time available, I would wait longer to make this post.

Ross artfully avoids accusing me of bullying, while interjecting that very same idea into the public debate. Ross certainly knows that the meme of Chris Daly as bully is out there. It’s unfortunate that he would be using these unprincipled attacks on a progressive Supervisor to his personal advantage.

To the contrary, while Ross has been making the tough sell to colleagues, I have largely been hands-off in the internal lobbying efforts for Board President. I’ve made my position known publicly, but I have only initiated 2 conversations with colleagues about the Board Presidency. I expect political projection from the Newsom camp, not from my progressive colleague.

The Case for John Avalos

District 11 Supervisor-Elect John Avalos and Supervisor Chris Daly on election night.
Photos by Luke Thomas

By Chris Daly

January 4, 2009

John Avalos, Community Organizer

District 11 Supervisor-Elect John Avalos

I first met John Avalos back in 1999 at his old place in the Excelsior, across from Monroe Elementary School. By this time, John was already well known in community organizing circles for his work at Coleman Advocates for Children and Youth. John and his partner, Karen Zapata, had opened up their home as the Excelsior mobilizing spot for Tom Ammiano’s campaign for Mayor. I can remember thinking how lucky we were to have such a great connection in the Excelsior, a neighborhood that had been notoriously difficult for progressives.

Between 2000 and 2004, John served as the Director of Organizing for Coleman Advocates for Children and Youth and as Political Director for Justice for Janitors, SEIU Local 1877. At Coleman, John led the citywide outreach effort to pass the reauthorization of the Children’s Fund. He also brought Coleman to the next level of advocacy around the City budget, organizing service providers and residents to directly engage on the defining questions facing City Hall decision-makers. At Justice for Janitors, John mobilized political support for 2 contract campaigns, ensuring that over 2000 workers received wage increases while preserving healthcare and retirement benefits.

City Hall Savvy

In early 2005, I invited John to work as a Legislative Assistant in my office. It was one of the best decisions I have made as a Supervisor. Over the last 4 years, I watched as John Avalos adroitly managed legislative and political affairs, always taking time to hear from everyone while watching out for our City’s most vulnerable.

Most notably, John was able to use his experience as an organizer to open City Hall’s doors to ensure that the voices of San Francisco’s most vulnerable communities were clearly heard during budget deliberations. John was able to demystify the budget process for community stakeholders while coordinating sometimes-tedious budget discussions between Supervisor offices, the Budget Analyst, Controller, and Mayor’s Budget Office. John played much of this role at City Hall even in the years that I didn’t Chair the Budget Committee. Through John’s work, tens of millions of dollars worth of vital services for childcare, health and mental health programs, park restorations, and senior support were saved from the chopping block. And tens of millions more were added for affordable housing and other programs.

Let’s be honest here, there are several Legislative Assistants that are more involved in the day-to-day running of local government than many members of the Board. John was one of these “leg aides” and was known as the go-to-guy on budget matters. His even-handed work on the City budget drew strong praise across the political spectrum with accolades from Supervisors Sean Elsbernd and Ross Mirkarimi!

On the Frontline for Justice

We all have some experience in supporting a candidate for office and then being disappointed with their performance once elected. Maintaining the accountability of elected officials to the progressive communities who elect them is as important as winning elections in the first place. Over the years I’ve noticed that there are 2 indicators of how responsive a politician will be to progressive politics. The first is rooted-ness in community. The second is sense of justice.

While John’s roots in community are deep, his desire for social justice is even stronger.

In 1999, when John Avalos learned of the wrongful conviction of David Moreno and Justin Pacheco for a murder they did not commit, he launched a media campaign through We Interrupt This Message to free the two Latino youth from jail. By generating national coverage of the case and, generally, of racism in the criminal justice system, John was able to help Moreno and Pacheco win a not guilty verdict on all charges and their freedom. You can’t find John’s fingerprints on this case. He didn’t do it for personal gain or advantage. He did it because it was the right thing to do.

John has witnessed the injustice that the system can deal out, and it doesn’t just inform his outlook. It drives John to fight for justice at every turn.

Perseverance Through Adversity

My other measure for elected officials is how they respond to crises, which seem to come up far too often in local government. When it comes to tough times, the Avalos family has been put to the test. John’s daughter Rene was born 16 weeks early during a family trip. Rene battled for her life, and after 4 months and 2 hospitals, she made it home. Through it all, John was a Super-Dad. Not only was he glued to Rene’s bedside, he also navigated the complicated hospital bureaucracies and managed interactions with doctors, nurses, and hospital administrators to make sure Rene got the care she needed. Faced with the adversity of his first child’s life in the balance, separated from his home, and with skyrocketing medical bills, John was able to draw from a community of support, and rally through.

John Avalos, Emiliano, Rene and Karen Zapata.

John Avalos for President of the Board

I support John Avalos for Board President because I believe he is the best choice to lead the new progressive Board during these tough times. His progressive politics are grounded in decades of community and labor organizing work and a profound desire for social justice. John is universally liked and respected and has an uncanny ability to bring people together.

Supervisor-elect Avalos may know more about the City budget than I do, even with my 8 years on the Board, thrice as Budget Chair. This is important because, with the current financial crisis, the City budget is likely to occupy the new Board for the better part of the next 2 years. It would be smart for the Board to elect the Supervisor with the most hands-on budget experience to our top leadership spot.

John has assembled what will be the most experienced and diverse staff at the Board. Rachel Redondiez brings 8 years at the Board with her own impressive record of community and labor organizing. Francis Hsieh has 4 years at the Board plus another 2 as an aide in Sacramento. She comes back to City Hall from her position as Deputy Director of NARAL Pro-Choice California. Coupled with John’s 4 years at City Hall, the Avalos office isn’t just going to be prepared; they are ready to lead on day one.

Despite all this experience, John Avalos will be a new face for change in San Francisco politics. This little piece here is probably the most extensive column ever published about John. John’s fresh face fits neatly with the mantra for progressive change that has just swept across the country. With a community organizer and relative outsider set to take the keys to the White House, a John Avalos Presidency at the Board would make for very good symbolism.

This fall, John assembled one of the most sophisticated and well-organized progressive political campaigns that this City’s seen. Like Eric Mar and David Chiu, he took some of downtown’s toughest hits and proved his political mettle. John has helped politically transform what was a conservative neighborhood into one that is very much in play for progressives. (In addition to electing John, District 11 was one of five to support the Affordable Housing Charter Amendment.)

The recent release of Gus Van Sant’s biopic not only elevates the stage for the San Francisco Board of Supervisors; it also provides us with the opportunity to turn the tables on the definition of the Supervisor from the Excelsior. Think about the meaning of a progressive Latino Board President, from the neighborhood that used to be known for producing Dan White.

John Avalos is ready to walk in a proud line of progressive Board Presidents, as a community and labor organizer who has battled through adversity with a passion for social justice.

Co-hosted by

San Francisco Labor Council

&

San Francisco Democratic Party

Thursday, November 20^th

7:00 PM

628 Divisadero Street

(at Fell)

We hope you can join us to celebrate the tremendous victories we won on November 4^th !

Please call Emily Nelson at (415) 440-4809

for more information or to RSVP.

OPEIU3 AFL-CIO 11